MINDHUNTER

There's little that's conceptually different in crime drama Mindhunter. It takes its cue from films like Silence of the Lambs and tries to craft a series with a 70's vibe.

Regrettably, on its own this is not enough to carry this series. It needed more but fails to deliver. Its not helped by a rather pretentious and at times silly take on criminal profiling. It wants to be taken seriously but really it has more in common with corny series like Criminal Minds, than it might care to admit.

On the upside its watchable, as its topic is inherently interesting in a morbidly depressing way and the acting is fair.

By all means take a look but don't expect anything special. 5/10 from me.

First season great, the psychology is very interesting, the plot is good, at the beginning it's a little slow but then it kicks in and you can't stop.

Second season... not so great, the plot is sloppy, part of the story has no ending, they completely deviate from their goal... The second season is pretty bad.

Amazing. The best true crime style show I've seen. Bummer that they didn't do so well with the ending though.

Review: MINDHUNTER (2017)

Score: 8/10

Mindhunter is a masterfully crafted, intellectually riveting series that, for its brief but impactful run, redefined the psychological crime drama. It is indeed a mixed bag, but one where the quality of its best elements is so exceptional that the whole remains essential viewing. The series plunges us into the late 1970s birth of the FBI's Behavioural Science Unit, where agents Holden Ford (Jonathan Groff) and Bill Tench (Holt McCallany) pioneer the art of criminal profiling by interviewing imprisoned serial killers to understand the "why" behind the violence.

What Soars (and Anchors the Score):

• The Pinnacle of Process Drama: The show's greatest strength is its methodical, almost clinical fascination with procedure. The interviews with real-life killers like Ed Kemper (a chillingly charismatic Cameron Britton) are some of the most tense, compelling scenes ever put to television. It's a show about the psychology of evil, dissected through conversation.
• A Stellar Cast: The acting from all three of the main cast is brilliant. Jonathan Groff perfectly captures Holden's obsessive, boundary-pushing ambition, while Holt McCallany provides the grounded, world-weary counterweight as Tench. However, Anna Torv is the piece that completes it. Her performance as psychologist Wendy Carr is a masterclass in subtlety and intelligence. She brings a cool, academic precision and a deeply guarded personal vulnerability that is utterly magnetic, making her the show's indispensable emotional and intellectual anchor.
• Season One's Mastery: Season one was a strong introduction into the Mindhunter world, and is worth watching just for Anna Torv's fascinating performance. It is a near-perfect season of television—a self-contained, slowly tightening psychological study that establishes the team, their groundbreaking work, and the profound personal cost of staring into the abyss.

What Falters (and Prevents a Higher Score):

• The Uneven Second Season: Not sure what happened in season 2... but it wasn't good, unfortunately. While ambitious in tackling the Atlanta child murders, the season felt narratively fractured. It juggled too many threads—the central case, Tench's devastating family crisis, and Wendy's sidelined personal life—without giving any the depth they deserved. The pacing was off, the political bureaucracy overshadowed the psychological profiling, and the spark of the first season dimmed.
• A Frustratingly Unfinished Legacy: I guess the writing was on the wall that it would be axed. Such a pity. The series' indefinite hold leaves a profound sense of narrative blue balls, with key character arcs and historical crime threads left permanently unresolved, which retroactively impacts the satisfaction of the journey.

Verdict:

Mindhunter earns its 8/10 on the towering strength of its first season, its unparalleled atmosphere, and its trio of phenomenal performances, especially from the understated powerhouse that is Anna Torv. It is a brilliant, haunting, and meticulously detailed look at the origins of modern criminal psychology. The disappointing stumble of its second season and its untimely end prevent a perfect score, but what remains is still some of the most intelligent and unsettling television ever made.

Watch if: You love psychological thrillers, true-crime procedurals, character studies, and dialogue-driven tension. Skip if: You require fast-paced action, conventional narrative closure, or are sensitive to dark, psychologically heavy subject matter.